We Are Buying - Sell Us Your Cards

What We’re Buying

Rookies 2 Goats is always looking to add great cards and collections to our inventory. We buy sports and non-sports cards, both raw and graded, from individual cards to complete collections.

We are especially interested in:

Sports Cards
Baseball, Football, Basketball, Hockey, Soccer, UFC/Boxing, Golf, Racing, and other sports.

Raw Cards
Rookie cards, top prospects, autographs, numbered cards, parallels, refractors, short prints, inserts, vintage cards, high-end singles, and collections.

Graded Cards
PSA, BGS, SGC, CGC, TAG, and other reputable grading companies. We are especially interested in high-grade rookies, key cards, modern hits, vintage slabs, and desirable low-population cards.

Non-Sports Cards
Pokémon, Marvel, Star Wars, Disney, DC Comics, Garbage Pail Kids, and other collectible cards.

Every offer is based on current market value, recent comparable sales, condition, demand, rarity, and resale potential.

How It Works

  1. Submit: Send your card details and clear front/back photos.
  2. Review: We review recent sold comps, condition, rarity, and demand.
  3. Preliminary Offer: If interested, we may make a preliminary offer based on the information provided.
  4. Inspection: If cards are mailed or brought in, we inspect condition and authenticity.
  5. Final Offer: We confirm the final purchase amount after inspection.
  6. Payment: Once the final offer is accepted, payment is issued using the method and timeframe confirmed with you before shipment or handoff.

Most complete submissions are reviewed within 1–3 business days after we receive your card details and photos. Larger collections or high-volume periods may take longer.

Do not mail cards until Rookies 2 Goats authorizes the shipment and provides instructions.

Ready to Sell?

Send us photos and details of what you have. Our team will review your submission and follow up by email, whether or not we can make an offer.

Fair offers. Simple process. Collecting Greatness one card at a time.

SUBMIT YOUR CARDS

Submit Your Cards

Complete the form below and provide as much detail as possible. Fields marked * are required. Player / Character and Asking Price are optional.

Submitting a card does not guarantee an offer or purchase. Any offer based on photos or submitted information is preliminary until the item is physically inspected when applicable.







For mixed lots or collections, you can leave this blank.









Leave this blank if you would like us to make an offer.



You may submit now and send photos later. Share links that open without requesting access, or email clear front and back photos. Review begins once we receive your card details and photos.


If you leave the photo links blank, email your photos after submitting using the same email address entered above and include your name so we can match them to your submission.